The Endowment Effect

I am sure many of you have come across this term somewhere, probably in the books on economics… but here’s a twist:

” Did you know this effect is “everywhere” & and it impacts us on a daily basis?”

I realized this while I was preparing for a project and came across this article a very common experience we all encounter in our lives. How often do we go shopping? And how often we buy stuff “we didn’t intend to buy then”? How many times we end up buying stuff that we know it’s overly priced YET end up buying? Sound familiar? Let me explain why and how we end up getting trapped through a simple example. It’s a nasty trick we play on ourselves. What happens when we visit a clothing store for example and get attracted to an expensive piece of clothing? In spite of the high price tag, we end up visiting the fitting room to try it on. Right? We check out ourselves in the mirror from every angle and start projecting thoughts of how we will look in a business meeting or how it will look while going on a date? What people will say? Etc. And very soon the price tag begins to get justified and we find ourselves day dreaming with a smile. This smile is proof that our brain has been hijacked!!   By … the ENDOWMENT EFFECT !

The term “Endowment effect” was coined by economist Richard Thaler and later propagated by the Nobel Prize winning Psychologist and economist Daniel Kannehan. It means that people place a higher value on objects they perceive they own than objects they do not. It is somewhat linked to loss aversion theory which means that that people experience the hurt of losing something much more than the gain of acquiring it. Endowment effectThe Endowment effect stipulates that after people own something and after they have established or imagined a “property right” to the object then that something dramatically increases in subjective value.

This is what happens to us in the fitting rooms!  By putting on that piece of clothing we at that point endowed ourselves with the item and the thought of putting it back on the shelves gives a sense of “loosing” something which we don’t even own and suddenly we come out of the fitting room with a decision !  The decision to purchase!

Viola! “Endowment effect” in action!   Lesson?  “Do not enter the fitting room if you do not need it”.

We can see this endowment effect in action in many spheres of our lives. For example, real estate prices are often subject to this effect, with the sellers asking a price which exceeds consumer willingness to pay. On a smaller level, you can probably see it if you look around your house and think about the value of the items you own. For example, how much do you think the chair that you are sitting on is worth?

How often have you heard the phrase  “this has sentimental value”  applied to an object?  This cognitive bias is also known as Divestiture Aversion (Endowment effect), referencing the idea that because people become attached to objects they own, they often develop an aversion to selling them or passing them on. One extreme example of this bias is what leads many of us to develop habit of hoarding resulting in filled to brim basements which objects we once owned but can’t let go.

Some of the extremely high starting bids on eBay auctions is another example of endowment effect in action.

This endowment effect underlies and is interspersed across the entire sales and marketing principles. Sales people are trained to “avoid the endowment effect” especially during negotiation. The lesson they are taught are “you don’t own the customer”! Thus alerting to the trap.

Price trend / price elasticity are commonly used terms in marketing which also flirt with the principle of endowment effect. The “status” brands like Channel, Louis Vuitton, Prada etc. all use endowment effect to great extent.

The one contribution that endowment effect has made to the world of economics has been a reworking of the understanding of the relationship between willingness to pay for items, and willingness to accept compensation for such items. As a general rule, people are willing to pay less for items they don’t own, and they expect more compensation to sell the items they do own & here is another twist –  that  “this contradicts traditional economic theory. Go figure!

The impact of The Endowment effect to our daily lives is so great that it seems almost every aspect of our daily existence is influenced by it in one way or another, I wonder about instances where endowment effect is in action in the realm of personal relationships? If endowment effect is all about “perception of value” applied to an inanimate object, can this “perception” be applied to what we value the most in our lives – RELATIONSHIPS?

Doesn’t the endowment effect reflect the “it is mine” thought process?  If so then, isn’t the “mine concept” the crux of all relationships? My Family, My GF/BF, My Wife, My Children, My Friend … etc. etc.  endowment_effect_616x296Isn’t it that we place tremendous value on all “My” relationships and not so much “not my” relationships?  If so then is this “the endowment effect” in action?

We commonly hear phrases especially in a love/hate relationships like “he is so possessive… “, “She is obsessed with him..” etc. . Are such feelings of possessiveness or obsession result of “the endowment effect”?   If so, does this affect us in such a way that we end up treating our loved ones as “objects”?  Hence such feelings?

Are relationships susceptible to the “the claim of ownership”?

The results of this effect can sometimes be quite interesting, and being aware of it can be very important whether you are buying or selling something or in a relationship.

As I continue to ponder & before the endowment effect hijacks my brain, I leave you with another mega twist question-

“Is Marriage, the ultimate expression of commitment spawned by “THE ENDOWMENT EFFECT”??

I hope you liked this twist,  please feel free to add your twists , post comments / share your thoughts… 🙂

The Dichotomy of FreeConomics

 What if I told you , Nothing is free. 

 The only thing really Free are the Natural resources! Rest of everything “labelled” FREE is.. paid by you! 
 Welcome to the world of FreeConomics !

The word “Free” is considered to be one of the most powerful words in the world of advertising today. Psychologists say that 93% of the people would fall for this word and would be “compelled” to perform action linked to that word ! No matter what it is.


So much is the power of this single word that a “whole economy”  is shaping around this word. or in other words, its changing the way commerce is done today. It’s all about how cleverly an advertiser harnesses the power of this word.  Let me give some examples from the many we encounter everyday:

 

1. Buy two and get third FREE ! (now you will end up with three of the same things though you needed just one to begin with the Free word made you spend MORE). And we wonder “how come space in our homes is never enough?” 

2. Free gift with every purchase. Best way to increase sales of a product/ service. We don’t even know what gift is inside. Yet people purchase.

3. Pizza companies are one of the best examples of the use of word FREE in advertising.

4. Mother of all “freebies”.. FREE TRIAL!!  Okay, but not without filling out a “simple” information  form! (there goes your personal data to a service provider Watch out for your Inbox!)

 5. Social Media is FREE.  Everyone is ON it. But is it REALLY free ?

 

History of this “twist” in advertising is not very old. However its use is on the rise. Every product/ service provider seems to be using it now. Consumers have come to expect something SHOULD come free with their purchase. However small, yet they will claim that FREE prize. & feel accomplished ! 


Think about it. Let me prove it to you by using the example of this FREE blogging site – Blogger itself !  its Free! right? but did we not fill out a form and made a profile?So for opening a FREE blogger account , I had to give up my information! 

 

The Twist: By volunteering this information,  I PAID FOR THE FREE SERVICE 

 In order to get something FREE , we have to give up something in return!

An exchange has to take place. 

 

Another example is Social media platforms. It’s not free ! Facebook , Twitter etc are not free! 

We PAY for it with our “privacy”. As soon as you give up your privacy through volunteering the information & personal details , your PAYMENT is done ! Oh…they do provide this valuable feature called “privacy setting”. But hang on a sec ! there is ….

The Twist: Do those settings allow you to keep your information “private” from the service provider to whose FREE service you have subscribed to? 


Recently, Facebook created a buzz in Economic markets by announcing the take over of Whatsapp application for 13 bn Dollars !!! A Free service buying another Free service !! Where did this money come from? you would be right, if you said , through advertising and sponsors etc. But you would be WRONG if you said, I didn’t pay anything to either of the service provider! 

 The Twist : You PAID with your TIME !

 It’s this invisible yet extremely valuable currency we PAY for free service. Advertisers are “purchasing” YOUR TIME  to bombard you  with “advertising messages” every TIME you use this FREE service ! Of course there is an option if you don’t want to allow this “invasion of privacy” & “abuse of currency called Time” & here comes …

 

The Twist : You have to PAY for this “Upgrade” of service. It’s NOT FREE ! 

 

The other day my friend ordered pizza for our family from Pizza Hut. Upon delivery, we got ONE MORE FREE extra pizza. We inquired and were told that because our staff did not cut the pizza in the “shape”we requested, one extra pizza is on the house ! And i could see the expression of “achievement” on my friends face, but  it hit me! While she was delivering the awesome smelling pizzas to the dinner table, I was thinking about numbers – CHOLESTEROL numbers ! Now we will consume that Extra Pizza (Mind you, it was a Cheese loaded pizza) with satisfaction and even thank Pizza Hut for “awesome”service blah blah.

 

The Twist : What did I PAY for this FREE pizza ? 


Which one of the three options is the best answer?

a) Probably will order AGAIN from Pizza Hut in the (VERY) near future & hope they screw up again and get a FREE pizza.= More business for Pizza Hut. 


b) Probably with mine & my families HEALTH (with all that extra cheese). By this over consumption, I put myself and my family at increased risk of heart disease etc. 


c) ALL of the above ! 


So much of commerce takes place just by the use of word “FREE”. The VALUE of this twist (word Free) is literally fueling the growth of the economy& consumerism that to an extent it is actually helping the country to come of recession.


I am reminded of a very popular marketing book published in 1999 by Seth Godin – “Permission Marketing : Turning strangers to friends & friends to customers“. Read the underlined words again & think how vital the word “Free” is in the “commerce of consumerism”.

I hope you enjoyed your “Free” ride  in the world of “FREE-CONOMICS: A Economy with a twist” & thank you for your payment ! 🙂 

Finally, as a token of my appreciation for reading this blog, I leave you with…..

THE  FINAL  TWIST 

  It  is actually  POSSIBLE  to  live  entirely  WITHOUT  MONEY ! 

There is official movement called FREECONOMY began by a Bristol,UK resident Mark Boyle. He, in association with a not-for-profit organisation (Street Bank) has membership of over 3000 (as of 2008) in 54 countries !

 Click on the link below to believe this possibility! 

I look forward to your comments & thoughts.